Skip to main content
UNITED STATESIMMIGRATION DEFENDERS

Motion to Reopen an Immigration Case: Deadlines and Exceptions

A motion to reopen asks an immigration judge or the Board of Immigration Appeals to look at a closed case again because new facts or evidence may change the result. The rules are strict, but important exceptions may apply depending on the order, the reason for missing court, and current law.

Last substantive update:
Author:
USIDLAW Editorial Team

What a Motion to Reopen Does

A Motion to Reopen an Immigration Case is a written request to EOIR, the Executive Office for Immigration Review, asking that a completed immigration court or Board of Immigration Appeals case be reopened. Reopening is different from an appeal. An appeal usually argues that the earlier decision had a legal or factual error based on the record already before the court. A motion to reopen usually depends on new facts, new evidence, or a new basis for relief that was not previously available.

Under the EOIR regulations, a motion to reopen must generally state the new facts to be proven and must be supported by affidavits or other evidence. If the person is asking for relief such as asylum, cancellation of removal, adjustment of status, or another immigration benefit, the motion often must include the relevant application and supporting documents. Eligibility depends on the individual facts and the law in effect at the time the motion is filed.

The official rules for motions before an immigration judge are found at 8 CFR 1003.23. The official rules for motions before the BIA are found at 8 CFR 1003.2. These regulations should be checked directly because immigration rules and agency procedures can change.

The General 90-Day and One-Motion Rule

In most cases, a person gets one motion to reopen, and it must be filed within 90 days after the final administrative order of removal, deportation, or exclusion. This is often called the 90-day rule and the one-motion rule. The deadline is counted from the final administrative decision, which may be the immigration judge’s decision if no timely appeal was filed, or the BIA’s decision if the case was appealed.

Where to file depends on who last had control over the case. If the immigration judge entered the final order and there was no BIA appeal, the motion is usually filed with the immigration court that completed the case. If the BIA issued the last decision, the motion is usually filed with the BIA. Filing in the wrong place can cause delay or denial, so the procedural history matters.

The motion should be organized and supported. It should explain the deadline, the number of prior motions, the new facts, and why the evidence was not available earlier. A motion may also need a filing fee or a fee waiver request under current EOIR instructions. A general motion to reopen does not automatically stop ICE from carrying out removal in every case, so a separate stay request may be needed.

In Absentia Orders and the 180-Day Rule

An in absentia order is an order entered when a person did not appear for a scheduled immigration court hearing. Special reopening rules apply. If the person missed court because of “exceptional circumstances,” the motion to reopen and rescind the in absentia order generally must be filed within 180 days of the order. Exceptional circumstances can include serious illness, domestic violence, death of an immediate family member, or other serious events beyond the person’s control, but the facts must be documented.

There are also situations where an in absentia order may be challenged without the same 180-day limit. For example, a motion may be available if the person did not receive proper notice of the hearing, or if the person was in federal or state custody and the failure to appear was through no fault of the person. Notice issues are very fact-specific and may depend on addresses filed with the court, notices mailed by EOIR, and whether the person complied with address-change requirements.

Some in absentia rescission motions may carry special stay protections under the regulations, but this should not be assumed without reviewing the exact case posture and rule. Anyone facing ICE contact or a removal risk should seek case-specific guidance quickly.

Common Exceptions to the Time and Number Limits

Several exceptions may allow a motion to reopen even after 90 days or after a prior motion. One major exception involves asylum, withholding of removal, or protection under the Convention Against Torture based on changed country conditions. The evidence must usually show material changes in the country of nationality or removal country, and the evidence must not have been available or discoverable at the earlier hearing.

Other exceptions may apply in specific categories, including certain cases involving domestic violence, abuse, or qualifying family relationships under immigration laws. These exceptions are technical and depend on the statute, the type of prior order, filing history, and the relief requested. A change in personal circumstances alone may not be enough unless it connects to a recognized legal basis for reopening.

Equitable tolling may also be argued in some cases, such as where ineffective assistance, fraud, or extraordinary circumstances prevented timely filing and the person acted with reasonable diligence. These arguments require careful evidence and may require compliance with special procedural steps, especially in ineffective assistance claims. EOIR is not required to grant reopening simply because an exception is argued; the person still must meet the legal standard.

Joint Motions to Reopen

A joint motion to reopen is a motion filed with agreement from both sides, usually the noncitizen and the Department of Homeland Security. Under the EOIR regulations, joint motions are generally not subject to the same time and number limits that apply to ordinary motions to reopen. This can make a joint motion an important option in some cases.

A joint motion is not automatic. DHS must agree, and DHS may decline for many reasons. A request to DHS should be supported with the final order, procedural history, proof of eligibility or humanitarian factors, and a clear explanation of why reopening is appropriate. The immigration judge or BIA still must decide whether to grant the motion.

Joint motions may be considered where there is a strong new eligibility issue, a notice problem, a government error, a pending or approved USCIS petition, or other significant equities. The best approach depends on the record and current agency policy, which should be confirmed before filing.

Evidence, Safety, and How USIDLAW Reviews These Cases

A strong reopening request usually starts with the complete record: immigration court orders, BIA decisions, hearing notices, proof of mailing addresses, prior applications, ICE documents, USCIS receipts or approvals, criminal records if any, and evidence supporting the new claim. The motion should connect each piece of evidence to the legal reason reopening is allowed.

Be careful with personal information. Do not share your Social Security number, passport number, A-number, or other sensitive immigration information in public website forms, comments, social media posts, or public reviews. A consultation can use secure intake methods to collect what is needed for review.

Our team reviews the deadline, the forum, the prior case history, possible exceptions, and whether a stay request or DHS joint-motion request may be appropriate. No outcome can be promised. Reopening is discretionary, and eligibility depends on the facts, the evidence, and current law.

Sources

Discuss your situation

Book a free consultation with an immigration expert or send a request.

WhatsAppFree consultation