Skip to main content
UNITED STATESIMMIGRATION DEFENDERS

Evaluation of Available Removal Defenses

When someone is placed in removal proceedings, the first critical question is not just what ICE alleges, but what defenses may be available under current immigration law. Our team conducts a structured Evaluation of Available Removal Defenses for people in EOIR immigration court, people with prior orders, and families trying to understand realistic next steps.

We review possible relief and procedural options, including asylum-related protection, cancellation of removal, adjustment of status, waivers, voluntary departure, and prosecutorial discretion. Eligibility depends on individual facts, deadlines, criminal history, immigration history, family relationships, and the current rules used by USCIS, ICE, EOIR, the BIA, and DOS.

Book a Consultation

What issue this addresses

Removal defense is fact-specific. A person may appear ineligible for one option but have another path that depends on details such as date of entry, lawful status of relatives, prior applications, fear of harm abroad, criminal records, or whether DHS has filed correct charges. Missing a deadline, conceding facts too quickly, or overlooking a waiver can seriously affect the case. A complete screening helps identify defenses before pleadings, filings, hearings, or voluntary departure decisions are made.

Who this consultation is for

  • People who received a Notice to Appear and have a hearing in immigration court
  • Families trying to understand whether asylum, cancellation, adjustment, or waivers may apply
  • Individuals with old removal, deportation, or exclusion orders who need a risk and options review
  • Noncitizens with arrests or convictions who need screening before admitting removability
  • People considering voluntary departure or prosecutorial discretion and wanting to compare risks
  • Individuals who previously filed with USCIS or DOS and are now in EOIR proceedings

What we evaluate

  • Asylum, withholding of removal, and protection under the Convention Against Torture, including filing deadlines, past harm, future risk, and corroborating evidence
  • Cancellation of removal for lawful permanent residents or certain nonpermanent residents, including residence, physical presence, good moral character, hardship, and criminal bars
  • Adjustment of status in proceedings, including family-based or other immigrant visa eligibility, visa availability, admissibility, and whether USCIS or EOIR has jurisdiction
  • Waivers of inadmissibility or removability, such as certain fraud, unlawful presence, criminal, or prior removal issues where a waiver may exist under current law
  • Voluntary departure eligibility, timing, bond or departure requirements, and consequences of failing to depart after an order
  • Prosecutorial discretion options with DHS or ICE OPLA, such as requests related to dismissal, administrative closure, continuances, or other discretion where available under current policy

Documents that help

  • Notice to Appear, hearing notices, prior immigration court orders, and any BIA decisions
  • USCIS receipts, approvals, denials, interview notices, biometrics notices, and prior applications
  • Passports, visas, I-94 records, entry documents, parole documents, and travel history summaries
  • Marriage, divorce, birth, adoption, and proof of U.S. citizen or lawful permanent resident relatives
  • Criminal court records for every arrest, including certified dispositions and charging documents
  • Evidence related to fear of return, hardship, medical issues, employment, taxes, community ties, or rehabilitation
  • Do not include Social Security numbers, passport numbers, or A-numbers in public website forms; sensitive identifiers can be reviewed through a secure consultation process

How the process works

  1. We collect the immigration timeline, court posture, prior filings, family facts, criminal history, and any urgent deadlines.
  2. We compare the DHS allegations and removability charges against the available records and current legal standards.
  3. We screen each major relief category, including asylum-related protection, cancellation, adjustment, waivers, voluntary departure, and discretion.
  4. We identify missing documents, evidentiary weaknesses, timing concerns, and questions that may require deeper review.
  5. We explain the possible options, risks, and next procedural steps so the person can make informed decisions.

Important limitations

An Evaluation of Available Removal Defenses is a legal screening, not a guarantee that relief will be granted or that removal will be stopped. Immigration judges, USCIS, ICE, the BIA, and DOS apply changing statutes, regulations, policies, and case law to the specific record. Some people may have no available defense, may be barred by criminal or immigration history, or may face strict filing deadlines. Outcomes depend on individual facts and current law.

Frequently asked questions

Can more than one removal defense apply at the same time?

Yes. A person may need to screen for several options at once, such as asylum-related protection, cancellation of removal, adjustment of status, waivers, and voluntary departure. Some options can be pursued together, while others require strategic choices based on timing and risk.

Does a pending USCIS application stop immigration court automatically?

Not always. A pending USCIS petition or application may be important, but EOIR proceedings usually continue unless the immigration judge grants a continuance, DHS agrees to a form of discretion, or another procedural option applies. Jurisdiction also matters because some applications are decided by USCIS and others by the immigration judge.

What is prosecutorial discretion in removal proceedings?

Prosecutorial discretion means DHS or ICE may choose how to handle a case, such as agreeing to dismissal, a continuance, or another procedural request when policy and facts support it. Availability must be confirmed under current official guidance, and DHS is not required to grant discretion.

Is voluntary departure always better than a removal order?

Not always. Voluntary departure can reduce certain consequences if the person qualifies and leaves on time, but it has strict requirements and penalties for failing to depart. It should be compared with any possible relief, appeal rights, family needs, and long-term immigration consequences before a decision is made.

Discuss your situation

Book a free consultation with an immigration expert or send a request.

WhatsAppFree consultation