Skip to main content
UNITED STATESIMMIGRATION DEFENDERS

Bona Fide Marriage Exemption Review for Marriages During Removal Proceedings

A marriage entered after removal, deportation, or exclusion proceedings have started can face a special immigration barrier. Under INA 245(e) and related rules, the couple may need to show that the marriage is real and was not entered to avoid immigration laws, often using clear and convincing evidence.

Our team reviews the facts, timing, immigration court posture, and supporting documents to help identify what may be needed for USCIS, EOIR, the BIA, or consular processing through DOS. If you contact us through an online or public form, do not include Social Security numbers, passport numbers, A-numbers, or other sensitive identifiers.

Book a Consultation

What issue this addresses

When a couple marries while one spouse is already in proceedings, USCIS or the immigration court may apply the bona fide marriage exemption before the marriage can support an I-130 petition, adjustment of status, or related relief. This is not the same as ordinary marriage evidence. The standard can be higher, and the record must address both the genuineness of the relationship and the timing of the marriage in a careful, organized way.

Who this consultation is for

  • Couples who married after an NTA was issued or after removal, deportation, or exclusion proceedings began
  • U.S. citizens or lawful permanent residents preparing or responding to an I-130 spousal petition issue
  • Noncitizen spouses in EOIR immigration court who may seek adjustment of status based on marriage
  • Couples who received a USCIS request for evidence, notice of intent to deny, or interview concerns about a marriage during proceedings
  • Families trying to understand whether a written bona fide marriage exemption request may be needed

What we evaluate

  • When the relationship began, when the marriage occurred, and when immigration proceedings started
  • Whether the case is currently with USCIS, EOIR immigration court, the BIA, ICE, or DOS
  • Whether the marriage evidence may meet the clear and convincing evidence standard
  • Prior immigration filings, court orders, continuances, appeals, and any removal history
  • Possible red flags, including short courtship, separate addresses, prior petitions, inconsistent records, or missing documentation
  • How to organize evidence so it directly addresses good-faith marriage and not immigration evasion

Documents that help

  • Marriage certificate, divorce decrees, and records showing both spouses were legally free to marry
  • Proof of shared residence, such as leases, mortgages, utility bills, or official mail
  • Joint financial records, including bank accounts, insurance, taxes, loans, or beneficiary designations
  • Birth certificates of children together, pregnancy records, school records, or family medical records when applicable
  • Photos, travel records, messages, call logs, invitations, and evidence of shared family events
  • Declarations from both spouses and selected third parties who personally know the relationship
  • Immigration records, including the NTA, EOIR notices, USCIS receipts, RFEs, NOIDs, prior I-130 filings, and court orders

How the process works

  1. A consultation reviews the marriage timeline, immigration court history, and current case location.
  2. Our team identifies which agency may decide each issue, such as USCIS for an I-130 and EOIR for adjustment in court.
  3. We review the available evidence against the clear and convincing evidence standard and flag gaps or inconsistencies.
  4. We help organize a focused evidence plan for a bona fide marriage exemption request or response, if appropriate.
  5. Before filing, we review the package structure for clarity, consistency, and agency-specific concerns.

Important limitations

A Bona Fide Marriage Exemption Review does not guarantee approval of an I-130, adjustment of status, termination of proceedings, reopening, release, or any other immigration result. Eligibility depends on the facts, criminal and immigration history, agency jurisdiction, evidence quality, and current law, which can change. USCIS, EOIR, the BIA, ICE, and DOS each apply their own procedures and may request more evidence or reach a different conclusion.

Frequently asked questions

What is the bona fide marriage exemption?

It is a legal exception for certain marriages entered while immigration proceedings were pending. The couple generally must show by clear and convincing evidence that the marriage was entered in good faith and not to obtain an immigration benefit improperly.

Is normal marriage evidence enough?

Not always. Couples often need stronger, better-organized evidence because the standard may be higher than in a routine spousal petition. The record should explain the relationship history, shared life, and timing of the marriage.

Who decides the issue, USCIS or the immigration judge?

It depends on the case posture. USCIS usually decides the I-130 spousal petition, while EOIR may decide adjustment of status if the noncitizen is in removal proceedings. The two processes can affect each other.

Can this review stop removal proceedings?

No result can be promised. The review can help identify evidence and procedural issues, but any continuance, adjustment, reopening, appeal, or other relief depends on the individual facts and the decision of the proper agency or court.

Discuss your situation

Book a free consultation with an immigration expert or send a request.

WhatsAppFree consultation