Convention Against Torture (CAT) Protection
Convention Against Torture (CAT) protection is a defense to removal for people who can show it is more likely than not that they would be tortured if sent to a particular country. The torture must be carried out by a government official, or by someone acting with the consent or acquiescence of a public official.
CAT claims are highly fact-specific and evidence-driven. Our team reviews country conditions, past harm, medical or psychological records, criminal history issues, and immigration court posture to help identify whether CAT withholding or CAT deferral may be available under current law.
What issue this addresses
People who fear return may be in removal proceedings before EOIR, detained by ICE, or facing an order of removal after prior immigration history. CAT protection can be especially important when asylum or withholding of removal may be barred because of deadlines, criminal convictions, or other issues, but the legal standard remains demanding and must be supported with detailed evidence.
Who this consultation is for
- People in immigration court who fear torture if removed to their home country or another country of removal
- Individuals who have been harmed before by police, military, prison officials, security forces, or groups tolerated by officials
- Detained noncitizens seeking protection from removal while their case is heard by EOIR
- People with criminal history concerns who may need to evaluate CAT deferral as well as other defenses
- Individuals with final or reopened removal proceedings who need a careful review of protection options
What we evaluate
- Whether the feared harm meets the legal definition of torture, not only discrimination, threats, or general violence
- Whether torture is more likely than not if the person is removed to the proposed country
- Whether a public official would inflict, consent to, or acquiesce in the torture, including willful blindness in some circumstances
- Whether past harm, detention, political activity, religion, ethnicity, gender, family ties, or other facts support the claim
- Whether criminal convictions, prior orders, or credibility issues affect CAT withholding, CAT deferral, or other relief
Documents that help
- Immigration court notices, prior orders, charging documents, and EOIR hearing information
- Any USCIS, ICE, BIA, or federal court decisions related to past immigration filings
- Police reports, medical records, psychological evaluations, photographs, or witness statements about past harm
- Country condition reports from reliable sources, including U.S. Department of State reports when relevant
- Criminal court records, certified dispositions, plea documents, and sentencing records if there is any arrest history
- Personal timeline describing past harm, threats, reporting to authorities, and why protection from the government was unavailable
- Do not submit Social Security numbers, passport numbers, A-numbers, or other sensitive identifiers through public website forms
How the process works
- Case review: We review immigration history, court posture, fear of return, prior harm, and any criminal or detention issues.
- Evidence planning: We identify what records, declarations, expert materials, and country condition evidence may support the CAT claim.
- Application and filings: In removal proceedings, CAT is commonly raised on Form I-589 and presented to the immigration judge with supporting evidence.
- Hearing preparation: We help organize testimony, explain the legal standard, and prepare for questions about credibility, government involvement, and risk of torture.
- Decision and next steps: Depending on the outcome, options may include compliance with the order, appeal to the BIA, motions, or other review if legally available.
Important limitations
CAT protection has important limitations. It does not by itself create a path to a green card, does not provide derivative status for family members, and generally protects only against removal to the country where torture is more likely than not. CAT withholding may be unavailable in some serious criminal cases, while CAT deferral may be more limited and easier for the government to revisit. No outcome can be guaranteed, and eligibility depends on individual facts, evidence, procedure, and current law, which can change.
Frequently asked questions
What must be proven for CAT protection?
The applicant must show that torture is more likely than not if removed, and that the torture would be by a public official or with a public official’s consent or acquiescence. General danger or poor conditions usually are not enough without evidence meeting the CAT standard.
Is CAT the same as asylum?
No. Asylum requires persecution based on a protected ground and has different benefits and bars. CAT focuses on the likelihood of torture and government involvement or acquiescence. Some people apply for asylum, withholding of removal, and CAT protection in the same immigration court case.
Can a criminal conviction prevent CAT protection?
A criminal conviction can affect eligibility, especially for CAT withholding. In some cases, CAT deferral may still be considered even when other protection is barred. The analysis depends on the conviction record, sentence, immigration history, and current law.
Who decides a CAT claim?
In many cases, an immigration judge in EOIR removal proceedings decides the claim, with possible appeal to the BIA. Other procedures may apply depending on detention, prior orders, reasonable fear screening, or federal court history.
Discuss your situation
Book a free consultation with an immigration expert or send a request.